Dean Wingrin, defenceWeb – 8 October 2018
The South African Navy (SA Navy) and its sea-going personnel are reaping double benefits as Exercise IBSAMAR VI 2018, the trilateral naval exercise between Brazil, India and South Africa, concludes its first sea phase.
Following hot on the heels of Exercise ATLASUR XI the biennial maritime exercise between South Africa, Brazil and Uruguay, IBSAMAR commenced on 1 October, with the first sea phase taking place between 4 and 6 October in the False Bay area.
The first sea phase is an integration phase, when the three navies familiarise themselves with each other. The second sea phase, from 9-11 October, increases the scale and level of complexity.
Brazilian naval Captain Sergio Ozorio, Combined Task Force Commander, notes that “the exercise is a very good experience for the three navies to exchange the skills, procedures and the interoperability of the three navies.”
This is echoed by Captain (SAN) Jasper van der Westhuizen, the South African Joint Task Group Commander, who explains that exercises with the much larger Brazilian and Indian navies is “fantastic” and “an excellent opportunity to work with navies of this stature.”
Commander Task Group India, Captain Ajay Theophilus, was equally supportive of the exercise, saying that “India finds South Africa and Brazil as very good friends and to prove this, we have come through really rough seas to be here. I’m sure each of us is going to learn from each other and we’re going to improve so that tomorrow, when the enemy is at our doorstep, we’re hand-in-hand and together against it.”
Hosted by South Africa, but with Brazil acting as lead nation, the exercise is best summarised by Commander Abdul Sayed, Executive Officer of SAS Amatola, as “enhancing our inter-cooperability with one another as southern Indian Ocean and Atlantic Ocean region counterparts. The purpose of Exercise IBSAMAR is to hone on our Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) as well as multinational cooperating procedures in which we focus this year primarily on the combating of piracy as well as three-dimensional warfare.”
As such, the exercises lined up until IBSAMAR concludes on 12 October includes force protection, anti-piracy, anti-air warfare, anti-submarine and anti-surface warfare exercises, surface firing, search and rescue and tactical procedures.
The very first exercise of Sea Phase 1, experienced by this defenceWeb writer whilst aboard SAS AMATOLA, occurred within minutes of departing the safety of Simon’s Town Naval Base, when the warship was attacked by two Namacura Harbour Patrol Boats mimicking Fast Incoming Attack Craft (FIAC), simulating an asymmetric threat when a departing vessel is at its most vulnerable. The warship mobilised its gun crews and weapons teams in order to deter, warn (and if required) neutralise the threat.
Given the SA Navy’s ever-shrinking budget, keeping South Africa’s warships operational and giving her crews enough sea days to train, qualify and gain experience is an ever-increasing challenge. Thus, the SA Navy has welcomed the two maritime exercises and is using the opportunity to train new combat, navigator and engineering personnel to expand on the capacity within the South African Navy.
A case in point is that aboard submarine SAS Manthatisi is a new submarine Commanding Officer in training.
“You cannot have a better situation than this to really test him. One of the things for him is to operate under air threat, so we’re going to use the aircraft for that as well,” says van der Westhuizen.
Officer Commanding of SAS Amatola, Captain (SAN) Cebo Gwala, continued that the exercise presents “a very valuable opportunity for the training of the Officer Commanding, where he is going to have to fare against a real threat that is not familiar to him.
“But also for all the (surface ship) Watch Keepers, safety when operating near a submarine becomes paramount and the opportunity to exercise with one in close proximity and still stick to the basics of safety as laid down internationally and domestically is going to be a bonus compared to paper and/or simulators,” he explains.
Exercise IBSAMAR also allows for the customary cross pollination of crew, in which senior personnel from each of the three services act as observers aboard the vessels of the other navies.
“The purpose of that, besides a show of goodwill and good faith,” explained Sayed, “is also to assist when there may be a potential communication breakdown. That there is someone from that particular organisation on board that is able to decipher what the potential communication problem is and rectify it.”
Indeed, language issues have been identified as one of the key risks during the exercise. English is used as the communication medium, which can be challenging for countries which are not English-speaking.
Another challenge, which all three navies are quick to acknowledge, is that of budget, or lack of it.
Van der Westhuizen told defenceWeb that the budget for Exercise IBSAMAR “is actually much less than what one would expect.” Although still a lot of money, “if you look at naval budgets and what defence exercises cost, then we’ve really done it on a shoestring budget, we’re getting a lot of bang for our buck!”
The South African Navy (SAN), as the host country, is providing most of the participating assets. This includes the frigate SAS Amatola, hydrographic survey vessel SAS Protea which variously acts as support vessel and enemy, submarine SAS Manthatisi and the Maritime Reaction Squadron (boats, reaction force, divers and boarding party).
The Indian Navy will be represented by the Kolkata class INS Kolkata stealthy guided missile destroyer with a Westland Sea King Mk.42B multirole helicopter and INS Tarkash, a Talwar-class frigate embarking a Ka-31 Helix B airborne early warning helicopter and a Marine force. Sadly, a P-8I long-range, multi-mission maritime patrol aircraft which was scheduled to take part was withdrawn shortly before the commencement of the exercise.
Brazil is represented by the frigate BNS Barroso (with an AS350BA Ecureuil helicopter onboard) and 1 Platoon Special Forces.
The South African Air Force (SAAF) will be providing a Super Lynx maritime helicopter, an Oryx transport helicopter, two Gripen fighters for anti-ship/anti-air warfare drills and a C-130BZ Hercules for maritime surveillance duties. The South African Military Health Service (SAMS) is represented by 1 Medical Task Group.
Back in port for a few days after the conclusion of the first sea phase, the three navies are happy with the outcome.
“The atmosphere is very serious and respectful between the navies,” says Ozorio, whilst Sayed says that “thus far it’s been (going) very well” and that the Brazilians, Indians and South Africans are “able to communicate effectively and we are able to concentrate on the task at hand.”
The SA Navy is certainly getting full benefit from Exercise IBSAMAR, because as van der Westhuizen articulated, “we only have this one opportunity to do as much as you can.”